x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   2 Lakh More Aspirants For NEET This Year | Magnitude 5.9 quake strikes southern Iran, no casualties reported | Now driving a taxi, auto no longer requires a commercial license | ‘Modi go home’ posters greet Prime Minister Narendra Modi in London | SC for fair trial in Kathua rape-murder case | Did not support lawyers' protest in Kathua case: Jammu HC Bar Association to SC | SC dismisses pleas seeking probe in special judge B H Loya's death case | World Liver Day 2018: 9 Foods That Help Cleanse Liver Naturally! | No end to embarrassment for Yogi Adityanath: UP Minister says Mayawati rule was better, later takes U-turn | 2 killed in Indonesia quake | Delhi set to get hotter | What Owaisi had to say about the Mecca Masjid blasts verdict | Narendra Modi in UK: PM sounds 2019 poll bugle in London, tries to rationalise burden of expectations on him | Rich Dogra heritage left to rot, thanks to uncaring officials | Where's Heritage Conservation Act? | Another recruitment scam in RMSA | 'Architect of AoA not invited to PDP's crucial meeting | Kathua case: Anti-social elements trying to assassinate character of my husband, daughter, alleges woman | Father of 5 brutally tortured by Kishtwar police | Why no protests over Kulgam Sex Scandal? | NHM slammed for holding 'useless' screening camps | Management unit to help in proper implementation of climate change plan | Swachh Bharat Diwas observed at Kishtwar | Sub junior karate team flagged off for national karate championships | Vomedh Rangmanch stages Shuhul Taaph-2018 | Major reshuffle in Forest Department | CBI will probe Kathua case whether or not Mehbooba Mufti wants it, says sacked BJP minister | Member of family that lost 5 members in Pak shelling provided govt job | Three KAS officers among 4 transferred | Cabinet reshuffle to take place any day after April 22 | Pak stooges activate stone-pelting modules in Kashmir | Hurriyat demands for Nizam-e-Mustafa under 'callipha' in J&K State | US to help India in resolving energy crisis | President Kovind condemns Kathua case as shameful | Something wrong with our society: Mehbooba Mufti | In Kathua, 14 ISM dispensaries sans docs | PHC Sudh Mahadev functions without Allopathic doctors | CIC's direction to DSEK to provide para wise info to aggrieved | 166 per cent more civilian fatalities in Jammu, Kashmir in 2017: MHA | Mobile internet services restored in Jammu | Counsel files petition in HC seeking direction to meet his client in jail | Court awards one year RI to Patwari for forging revenue records | Show more sensitivity in dealing with questions relating to fundamental rights of citizens: HC to Courts | HC quashes bail in minor's kidnapping, rape case | ET report upsets DIO Rajouri | 23 bovines rescued, 4 vehicles seized | Multi crore scam surfaces in Education Department | Political interference in SWD condemnable | Farooq Abdullah urges India, Pakistan to resume dialogue | J&K to soon get a State Commission for Protection of Child Rights | Notary licenses of 2 advocates suspended | Jammu-Srinagar highway closed, Mughal Road opened for one-way traffic | 8 years on, Azmabad-Atoli road awaits completion | MPEJ seeks end to deceitful politics | Kandi Chattri village without power for two weeks | MJR, SAD delegation call on Dy Chief Minister | 2 drug peddlers held with 18 gram heroin | Appointment of Public Notary: Law Deptt issues revised interview schedule | Notary licenses of 2 advocates suspended | Garbage dumped inside SDH Mendhar puts patients' health at risk | BJP's conflicting statements in Rassana case intriguing: Harsh | People suffer, hand pumps go dry | Sri Sri Ravi Shankar conferred international leadership award | "Swachh Bharat Diwas" organized | NSF seeks CBI enquiry in Rassana case | Agriculture Department organizes awareness camp | Umeed (JKSRLM) celebrates "Gram Swaraj Abhiyan" | GGF sensitizes students about SDG | National conference concludes CU Jammu | Inter School District Level Competitions concludes | DPS celebrates international heritage day | Shiksha Niketan organizes drawing competition | Mega Kabaddi event to begin on April 23 | Bikes Rally on eve of Parshuram Jayanti | KPS Barnoti conducts maths workshop | Carmel Convent School celebrates "World Heritage Day" | Students of GWC Gandhi Nagar visit Krishi Bhawan | JKBA junior B'ball gets underway | NHM launches 5-day training programme | PSA condemns Govt for imposing cases on Private Schools | HHM celebrates "World Heritage Day" | Red Cross organizes medical check up camp | Kashyap elevated as Director NYK J&K | Birth Anniversary of Madhu Param Hans celebrated | HWO awards Early Times correspondent, others | NDA organizes seminar on drugs control | Dismissal of Govt. only way to restore confidence of people in state: Prof Bhim Singh | Inter Zone Football Tournament concludes at Doda | AJKYF discusses issues of youths | CCPPWU criticizes postal service in Kishtwar | JTC, SKF raise issues of shortage of accommodation | Jodhamal School wins Inter School Table Tannis Tournament | Back Issues  
 
news details
AADHAAR INTRUSION "
Er Jaleel wani5/19/2017 12:02:35 AM
The system in India is the most sophisticated that I have seen and it should be good for the world if this became widely adopted" remarks by Paul Romer, a chief economist of the world bank regarding the Aaahaar program of India. Later World Development Report 2016 also mentioned that,"a digital identification system such as India's Aadhaar, by overcoming complex information problem, helps the government to promote the inclusion of disadvantaged group". This gives us a clear insight of the scheme started by the government of the India.
Aadhaar is one of the technological successes of India and is an initiative unparallel in scope anywhere else in the world. India is largest leading the way in the implementation of national identification program linked to biometric data. This data is collected by the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDIA), a statutory authority established last year by Government of India under the ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, under the provisions of Aadhaar Act 2016. No doubt as of now this system provided more than 113 crore residents of India an Aadhaar card which is roughly 88.8% of the projected population, is facing a legal battle to make it mandatory for Indian citizens in order to ensure efficient delivery of subsidies , benefits and services under Aadhaar act 2016. On August 2015, a three judge bench of the Supreme Court held in 'K.S. Puttaswamy case' that the production of an Aadhaar card would not be condition for obtaining any benefits otherwise due to a citizen. Also bench said that having regard to importance of the matter, it is desirable that the matter be heard at the earliest.
There after five judge constitution bench held in its interim order on October 2016 that," we will also make it clear that the Aadhaar card scheme is purely voluntary and it cannot be made mandatory till the matter is finally decided by the court one way or the other". This order also restricted the use of the aadhaar number to six schemes namely, Public Distribution System(PDS), Subsidized LPG cylinders , Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme(MGNEGS), National Social Assistance Programme (old age pension, widow pension, disability pension), Prime Minister's Jan Dhan Yojna and Employee Provident Fund Organization(EPFO). Again Honorable Court in 'All Bengal Minority Students Council and Anr v/s UOI' case held that Aadhaar could not be made mandatory condition for any government scheme.
However the centre government issued a series of notification making it mandatory for purpose other than those permitted by the Apex court. For instance the Ministry of Micro Small Medium Enterprises made it mandatory for MSME to register online through Udyog Aadhaar , that too within 5 days of supreme court interim order. Scholarships under the University Grant Commission began to be restricted to Aaadhaar holder or those who had enrolled for it. Even CBSE insisted on Aadhaar for NEET test 2017 aspirants. Railway recruitment board made it mandatory for its examination.
Ministry of Human Resource Development made it mandatory for national means-cum-merit scholarship scheme and National scheme of incentive to girls for secondary education. From January this year Aadhaar enrollment became mandatory under National Food Security Act and Employee Pension scheme. Recently section 139AA of income tax act 1961, as amended by Finance act 2017, provide for mandatory quoting of Aadhaar or enrollment ID of Aadhaar application form to file income tax return and to make an application for allotment of Permanent Account Number (PAN). Also in this regards even states were not holding back. The candidates for Utter Pradesh state common entrance test were required to furnish Aadhaar number. Andhra-Pradesh engineering, agriculture and medicine common entrance test was also restricted to Aadhaar holder. In short Government of India is continuously expanding the requirement of Aadhaar for various services. While there is doubt that the purpose behind making Aadhaar mandatory is to simplification of delivery process ranging of service to the citizen as well as distribution of benefits and subsidies which saved more than 36 crore in two years as per governments statistics, to bring transparency and efficiency, receipt of entitlements in a convenient and seamless manner, obviating the need to produce multiple document to prove ones identity. In general it is meant to streamline bureaucratic process for better governances. It is off course a mass surveillance technique as well , unlike targeted surveillance is good thing and essential for national security and public order and would be best remedy to combat a rising global phenomena of terrorism. Apart from these, few well renowned political scholars, strategic analysts and foreign policy composers suggesting that government should integrate the project into its neighborhood foreign policy agenda thereby countering Chinese companies who actually supplying digital network to them. Referring to this specific purpose Nandan Nilekani, the brain behind the unique identification concept said,'' other governments are already interested in its potential.
Countries such as Afghanistan, Bangladesh, and Tanzania have visited India to talk about this system". Besides purposes Aadhaar act raised serious issues which are awaiting resolution by the Supreme Court. One is the Aadhaar act is palpably arbitrary and illegal inasmuch as it creates an artificial impermissible classification between those entitled person who have parted with biometric and those entitled persons who have not parted with biometrics. This is a serious flaw, held violation of Article 14 of the constitution which guarantees equality before law and equal protection of law. Second is that state can't enact a law or create a system that by its very design and operation will place the state in an extremely dominant position in relation to every citizen. The state is under obligation under Article 13(2) of the constitution to ensure that it shall not make any law that takes away or abridges the fundamental right conferred under part third of the constitution.
Third is that the constitutional limitation as such that the government can't engage in surveillance of citizens even each of these citizens volunteer to be subject to surveillance. As a person has full dominion and control over her core biometric, just as she has her body and personal autonomy, any collection of personal biometrics can only be done through free and informed written consent on the part of the individual (issue relating privacy). Fourth is that taking of person's fingerprint and iris scan without informed consent is a physical invasion of his or her bodily integrity. Fifth is while engaging in the exercise of collecting biometrics, the government acts as a trustee at every stage. The role of trust, given the sensitive nature of the information must be exercised by the state or organs of the state alone and can't under any circumstance be delegated to private parties operating without any governmental supervision. The crucial stage of obtaining consent or informed consent is entirely in the hands of private players and thus against the principle of trusteeship. Sixth, this data of every citizen can pose serious problems to our country's internal security. There is always an urge to acquire such data by firms to market their products catering to individual specificities but the dangers will go beyond the mere urge for profit maximization.
Another aspect is that concerns of safety of data are related to the issue of cyber security. Even the most formidable firewall of NASA and Pentagon has been beached. Last but not the least is that the way Aadhaar bill was passed needs to review and check its constitutional validity. What needs to be done is that instead of arguing the privacy is not a fundamental right Government should assure the citizens that it has the technique and system to protect the data collected and will do everything possible to prevent unauthorized disclosure of or access of such data. This century comes with certain risks; therefore government should recognize both the need for Aadhaar and the need to stringent rules concerning access to and security of citizens' biometric data in order to preserve privacy.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU