x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   EC collaborating with Facebook to enrol new voters | Under drone surveillance, first batch of pilgrims leaves Jammu for Amarnath Yatra | Terror funding: Son-in-law of Syed Ali Shah Geelani, two other Hurriyat leaders, detained by J&K Police | KAS officers reluctant to pay income tax | USA sanctions on Salah-ud-din to wind-up Kashmir Militancy | Who leaked IGP's letter? Police to probe | Govt 'betrays' people by snubbing Punjabi language | Demand for withdrawal of security to separatists | MHA recommends DIG's name for posting in JKS range | Orphaned Azad loyalists seek his return to State politics | Lowest registration recorded for Annual Amarnathji Yatra in a decade | Capt Bana Singh holds motivational talk with girls NCC cadets | Laxmi Cricket Club, Provin Cricket Club log victories | 'Kayakalp' Man of Udhampur Hospital -Thrown into Oblivion | Scientific Cultivation of Maize | PM Modi Tumble's Pakistan in US | No Governor's rule disheartens NC & and Congress | Nat Manch stages Nukkad Play Drugs Ko Hathao | HSIC registers first win in cricket tournament | RCB excels in Subash Memorial Cricket Tournament | Gold Gym inaugurates Cross-Fit studio | Lt Col Jamwal scales Mt Denali | Uncertainty prevails over additional MBBS seats | Repeated damage to 4th Tawi Bridge exposes its technical soundness | After saying no to Minerals, Bashir Mir to be VC BOCWWB….. | J&K not homogeneous: Karan Singh | Despite heightened militant violence, Mata Vaishno Devi pilgrimage at peak | Kishtwar: Police identifies anti-India protesters | Protest of Polytechnic Academic Arrangements enter day 21 | Aadhaar row: No citizen will be deprived of social benefits, govt tells SC | Development can change the fate of public: Vibodh | Hunger strike of contractual lecturers enters 133rd day | In fresh warning to India, al Qaeda says will target those who kill 'Kashmiri brothers' | IETE holds annual general meeting | Comprehensive plan to develop Billawar as a model constituency: Dy CM | BSNL makes special arrangements for Amarnath Yatra | Jan expresses concern over LoC shelling | ReT deputation calls on HRD minister | Beopar Mandal announces 3-day summer vacations for shopkeepers | Why is BJP silent over PSC selection fiasco, questions Harsh | JU VC tailors rules to adjust favourite candidates: NSF alleges | Sathra hand pump goes dry for 03 yrs, authorities in slumber | All in place for Amarnath Yatra, security tightened along highway | High threat of militant attacks ahead of Amarnath Yatra, says BSF chief KK Sharma | Satellites, drones to monitor 40-day long Amarnath Yatra: DG CRPF | MS refutes allegations | HC orders to reserve 1 post of asstt prof under ST category | HC stays JMC notice to Vivo Mobiles | Lynching of Pandith heinous crime: Omar Abdullah | Bus driver saves passengers, before dying of heart attack | Train to Leh, Ladakh: Suresh Prabhu lays foundation stone for Bilaspur-Mandi-Leh Rail Line to be built at a cost of Rs 157 cr | Three IGPs shuffled | CJ condoles demise of sub-judge | Dalai Lama to celebrate 82nd birthday in Leh | After GST launch on July 1, will groceries, medicines go out of stock? | SHRC finds no police mischief in disappearance of Kupwara man | CAIT exhorts J&K CM to implement GST in state from July 1 | Dr. Vikas Sharma conferred with Young Scientist Award-2017 | Administration notifies 5 medical camps for July | ICELA to launch tree plantation drive | NCP welcomes decision of USA of declaring Sallahudin as global terrorist | Probe into criminal and corruption cases against MLA Ramnagar demanded | JPPF tours border village Arnia, takes stock of problems | KPC expresses dismay over apathy towards Kashmiri Pandits | Back Issues  
 
news details
The Jadhav case is best handled at the political level
5/19/2017 11:03:12 PM
M K Bhdrakumar.

Retired Indian Navy commander Kulbhushan Jadhav who has been sentenced to death in Pakistan. The initial reports from Pakistan regarding the International Court of Justice's interim order on the Kulbhushan Jadhav case give a sinking feeling. If chances of Pakistan carrying out the death sentence were evenly poised, the balance now tilts in favour of execution.
There has been heavy criticism of the Pakistani government's handling of the case at the ICJ by the Opposition parties.
The accusations range from inept handling to outright criticism that Pakistan should have altogether dissociated from the proceedings and refused to accept the ICJ's jurisdiction to the highly combustive allegations that there might have been some 'atch fixing' between Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Indian steel magnate Sajan Jindal's recent visit has been linked to that preposterous conspiracy theory. Without doubt, Sharif's government has been put on the back foot. It is now coming under compulsion to take a hard line. The Pakistan attorney general's office has vowed to take the case to its 'logical conclusion.' Information Minister Marriyum Aurangzeb said Pakistan will vigorously fight this case without compromising on its national security. 'Pakistan's security is so important,' Sartaj Aziz, Sharif's adviser for foreign affairs, said, 'and we have to maintain our fundamental sovereign right.' There has been no statement from the pakistan army so far. Evidently, the army will keep close tabs on the groundswell of public opinion, which seems to favour Jadhav's execution. The last date for Jadhav to appeal is May 19. But the timeline can be extended.
Any such extension will give a clue on the way the wind is blowing in the GHQ in Rawalpindi. Pakistan has already informed the ICJ that Jadhav will not be executed before August 10. It is safe to conclude that Pakistan will abide by the ICJ's interim order. What lies beyond that certainty is a 'known unknown.' Having come this far, the probability is that Pakistan will present its case more forcefully at the next ICJ hearing. Surprisingly, its performance at the ICJ hearing on Monday, May 15, was far below par -- conveying even an impression that an interim order was a near certainty and, therefore, why bother. It may have decided to keep the powder dry for the forthcoming hearing. From the various remarks in reaction to the ICJ's ruling, it is apparent that Pakistan remains ambivalent about the ICJ's jurisdiction. But the big question is whether this means that the door is open for it to refuse to comply with the ICJ's final judgment -- or even whether it will wait beyond August for the final judgment to come. The point is the decision to participate in the ICJ hearing in the first instance has been a deliberate one and taken obviously on the basis of careful consideration from the political and diplomatic angle. Pakistan would have weighed that India was making a historic departure from its reticence to seek third party intervention in India-Pakistan issues and it was important and necessary to establish a precedent.Pakistan will be closely analysing already the precedent this sets for it to bring Kashmir-related issues to the ICJ in the future.
After all, the human rights issue in J&K is of a much, much bigger dimension, considering that there are UN Security Council resolutions on self-determination that are yet to be implemented to which Pakistan also happens to be an affected party. And the prevailing situation in J&K is alarming. The UN secretary-general's spokesman is on record that the situation is being closely monitored in New York.
Significantly, when asked to comment on the ICJ case, the US state department proffered the advice that the Jadhav file is best handled by India and Pakistan through 'direct dialogue' and 'practical cooperation.'Both India and Pakistan are swimming in unchartered waters.
The bottom line is that on the one hand the ICJ ruling brings much relief that Jadhav's execution is not imminent and it no doubt assuages Indian public opinion, while on the other hand, the standoff at The Hague exacerbates India-Pakistan tensions and may ultimately put the Pakistani back up. Importantly, Sharif faces a crucial election early next year and cannot afford to look indecisive in August when th e ICJ's final verdict is expected. In the final analysis, ICJ verdicts are not enforceable either.Taking all factors into consideration, therefore, there is every reason to avoid any triumphalism from the Indian side over the ICJ ruling.To my mind, the Jadhav case is best handled at the political level.
The opportunity available on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation summit in Astana (June 8-9) must be fully exploited to open a conversation. Conceivably, the ICJ may take its own time to give the final verdict -- say, even 2 or 3 years -- and that would give us the respite to negotiate bilaterally to resolve the issue.
( Courtsey@rediff.com )
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
 
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU