x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Majority of DCs fail to act upon Guv's 3 yr old order | Jammu seething with anger | Amnesty for stone pelters, martyr's sacrifice goes unnoticed | Blue eyed officer of former CM got his man posted as director RDD | Lakhs spent like water in the name of 'Women Empowerment' | Eye on LS polls, BJP may befool Jammuites, again | Piles of rape cases in district courts expose successive Govts | BJP could again form govt with Mehbooba Mufti | Terror outfit LeT endorses Azad's statement | DDC Samba pays surprise visit to govt offices, suspends five employees | District Administration Samba, Baba Chamliyal Committee on loggerheads | Smuggling bid foiled, bovine rescued | JKSSM president tours far flung areas of Nagrota | Illegal Tendering for Advts in JU, NSF seek probe | SRS seeks withdrawal of cases on Amarnath land row agitators | AIKS hails Governor's Rule | Three days capsule course for office assistants begins | JTC & SKF hail smooth conduct of Kheer Bhawani Yatra | Sunil demands Guv to order shoot at sight on stone pelters in valley | Salani village without water | Holy Amarnath Yatra under threat | Tracking chips to be installed in Amarnath-bound vehicles: IGP | Officers posted in personal sections asked to go back to parent Deptts | Grenade attack on security forces' vehicle in Tral injures nine CRPF, JKP personnel | Govt makes biometric attendance compulsory for employees | Mehbooba Mufti govt was worst ever: Lal Singh | Assitt Development Commissioner accused of favouritsm | Sudhmahadev Mela Committee constituted | Youth Committee of AKRS Kishtwar framed | 4th International Yoga Day observed accross Kishtwar District | Vigilance books JE SSA Doda | Dir Agri inspects farmers' welfare programmes | JKSAC holds meeting of former Panches, Sarpanches | Natrang Theatre Festival concludes | NCC cadets conduct cleanliness drive | First aid training programme organized | Governor reviews arrangements at Holy Cave | Sports stadium Udhampur turns into cattle pond | Foolproof arrangements needed Holy Amarnath Yatra under threat | Doc couple made to stay in Gurez for years | Legislator manages to secure key posting for favourite Inspector | Junior docs being deployed for Amarnath Yatra | Tourists' visit to Sonamarg proves nightmare | Four ISIS militants killed at Srigufwara-Anantnag; cop, civilian also killed | Bloodshade on Chinar leaf | That's Life | Vohra need not be replaced during the current critical stage | PDP-BJP Govt's performance card is blank: Jan | Constitute COI to probe scams of coalition Ministers, MLAs: Harsh | Chaman Lal pays tributes to Dr SP Mookerji | Kabir Jayanti Shoba Yatra on June 24 | AJKYF expresses concern over unrest in State | Governor adviser to Vijay Kumar reviews security situation | Nirmal Singh inaugurates Vet hospital, inspects several dev projects | Male body found | MGNREGA Workers demand payment, stage protest | Power shut down | Governor meets leaders of political parties | Tariq Karra had beforehand 'intuitions' of PDP-BJP breakup | What will Guv do to overstaying police officials? | Security forces all prepped to stop militant recruitment at funerals in South Kashmir | Biannual mail of Khajuria biradari held | Back Issues  
 
news details
RTI seeking OMR sheets from JU: IC's order contradicts CIC's orders
5/20/2018 10:57:43 PM
Early Times Report
Jammu, May 20: The Information Commissioner (IC) of J&K State Information Commission (SIC), while disposing of an appeal filed against Jammu University, has upheld the order of the Public Information Officer (PIO) wherein he said that an information seeker can only get copy of his own OMR sheet.
However, the order issued by IC Mohammad Ashraf Mir contradicts the previous orders of Khurshid Ahmad Ganai, Chief Information Commissioner (CIC), who in several cases directed for providing answer key and copies of OMR sheets of other candidates as well.
Details available with Early Times reveal that an RTI application was filed by Omesh Sharma, a resident of Shastri Nagar, Jammu on 17-07-2017 before PIO University of Jammu. The information seeker had sought copy of the Answer Key/OMR sheets of the objective type questionnaire consisting of 90 questions of the examination held by the JU for the post of Assistant Registrar on 23-11-2002.
The JU informed the applicant that since the said information pertains to the year 2002, the same was not available in the university. Aggrieved, the applicant filed first appeal before First Appellate Authority (FAA)/Registrar, JU on 25-08-2017. The FAA disposed of the appeal observing that since the desired information was not available with the JU, as such the same cannot be provided to the applicant. The applicant challenged the order of the FAA by filing a second appeal before the SIC on 22-12-2107.
The appeal came up for hearing before the SIC on 08-02-2018. During the hearing the PIO submitted that the information sought for by the appellant pertains to the year 2002 and the same was not available with the JU. The PIO also submitted that as per the statutes of the JU, the records of examinations and score awards are required to be destroyed after three years of date of examination. As such the JU was not required to keep the records of 2002 available after a lapse of 15 years.
However, the appellant submitted during the hearing that he had filed a writ petition with respect to the same selection process of 2002 which was disposed of by the High Court in 2016 in which the court observed that the records on the selection have been made available to court. The appellant further submitted that if the records have been submitted to the High Court in the said writ petition why cannot the JU furnish the same to the appellant under RTI Act.
The case was accordingly adjourned and the PIO was directed to produce copy of the statutes with respect to destruction of records pertaining to examination selection process conducted by the JU and also try to get records which were made available to court so that same could be furnished to the appellant.
The appeal again came for hearing before the SIC on 15-03-2018. The PIO of JU furnished a copy of Answer Key as sought by the appellant and also OMR Sheet of the appellant pertaining to 'A series' which was relevant to the concerned appellant.
The counsel for the appellant submitted that he will consult the appellant and furnish the rejoinder by or before the next date of hearing. The appeal was accordingly adjourned. The appeal yet again came up for hearing before the SIC on 11-04-2018. The counsel for the appellant submitted that the Answer Key pertains to only 'A series' while the Answer key with respect to other series have not been furnished. The PIO submitted that the appellant was a candidate of series A during the said examination and only the Answer Key of series A can be provided to him under the RTI Act as the information with regard to rest of the series would amount to third party information.
"The SIC is an agreement with a stand taken by the PIO that the appellant can only claim Answer Key of his own series and his own OMR Sheet. The OMR Sheets of other candidates and the Answer Key of other series cannot be provided to the appellant as these documents are not relevant for the appellant. The SIC is therefore, satisfied that the information sought for by the appellant has been provided to him through his counsel during the hearing and not further remains to be adjudicated in the appeal by the SIC. The appeal is accordingly disposed of," reads order issued by the IC Mohammad Ashraf Mir.
Pertinent to mention that in a recent case Umar Rashid Bandari V/S Public Service Commission, CIC Khurshid Ahmad Ganai had directed the PSC to provide copies of OMR sheets of other candidates who appeared for a written test for the post of lecturer 10 +2 in 2017. The said information was not provided by PIO of J&K PSC to Umar Rashid earlier who sought OMR copies of some other candidates who had appeared for the written test with him. Even the First Appellate Authority (FAA) of PSC had rejected this information but CIC had ordered the information to be disclosed which was in-fact disclosed after CIC's orders. Now as IC Mohammad Ashraf Mir has issued the orders in this case it is contradicting with the CIC's orders which is a matter of concern.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU