x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Govt orders major reshuffle in administration | Raghunath Bazar Businessmen Association meets Div Com Jammu | Civil Defence Training Programme concludes | Lecturer allegedly commits suicide, parents allege murder | National Bone and Joint Day on Aug 4 | NIAC insures Hajis under SR | Two found dead | Former MP conducts three days tour of Rajouri and Poonch | Governor inaugurates SFA Football League Phase II | Tehsildar in dock for defying govt order | Is Edu deptt suppressing facts before Centre? | Governor's admin cuts Pak stooges to size | Nepotism rampant in LA secretariat | Setback to Crime Branch in Rassana case as envelope containing hair strand of victim was found empty in Court | 10 weeks after opening of Durbar, files remain confined to bags, boxes at Civil Secretariat | First Lady Usha Vohra e-inaugurates J&K Bank's first women branch | With no bridge, students swim across river to pursue education | DIET Reasi needs will to run institution | Accept your mistakes like NC did: Omar to Mehbooba | Chocked drains wreak havoc in Rajouri town | Govt falters on its promise of pucca house to urban dwellers | Seminar on 'Doctor-Patient Relationship' turns into political battlefield | Fruit rates in Jammu to be revised after 23 yrs | No separate toilets for female employees in most Govt offices | By allowing cross LoC trade Government compromising with nation's security, encouraging drug addiction in J&K | Atmosphere still not conducive for civic & Panchayat polls | Are you concerned about your relationship? | In competent Law Secretary Conspire to Kill Reservation in Promotions | Beef ban: Reality & Rhetoric! | Jammu Chamber of Commerce alleges discrimination, threatens agitation | Javadekar reviews progress of Education sector in 'Aspirational Districts' | Team Jammu urges Governor to plug drugs supply | Blackmailer harasses public: JKACF | National Awardee teachers deprived of Incentives | AAP Governor, to form elected Block Development Council, District Development Boards | ROF discusses issues of pensioners | Centre should get Lok Pal established: MPEJ | ESRM stages nukad "Jaan Hai Jahhan Hai" | CUJ organized the first NSS Special Summer Camp, 2018 | SKUAST-TAJ seeks enhancement in retirement age | ABDPSS arranges Bhandara for Amarnath Yatris | GDC Bishnah conducts door to door Swachhta campaign | Basic Shooting Course Inaugurated | Younger brother allegedly kills elder | NIA court sends Asiya Andrabi to judicial custody | Advisor Vijay Kumar reviews functioning of JKSFC | Ganai reviews functioning of Education Department | Landslide forces closure of new route to Vaishno Devi Shrine | Ex-MLA's guard killed as militants attack, loot weapons | HC refuse to quash PSA of drug peddler | 1 year imprisonment, Rs 3 lakh fine in cheque bounce case | D C Raina assumes office as new Advocate General | One killed, six injured as car collides with army truck | MGNREGA employees' stir continues, demand resolution of issues | Jammu athletes clinch 13 gold, 3 silver, one bronze | Rotary Club releases roaster for 2018-19 | SPCB carries out anti-polythene drive | Protest procession against drug-addiction taken out | Militant killed, two army men injured in ongoing encounter along LoC in Kupwara | Death of Amarnath pilgrim | ATFI chief filed petition against Mehbooba Mufti in Ambala court | DLL appointments, back-date service effect scandalous; VC made money: JYF | Non-functioning of Hospital Lifts: JKGGC seeks report | Siar Baba incident: Free treatment of injured at SMVDNSH | JeM outfit busted, three arrested in Sopore | Govt clarifies on revocation of Individual Arms Licenses | Govt issues guidelines for constitution of Interdepartmental Committees | Jammu Airport after Maharaja Hari Singh: Prof Gupta | Govt orders major reshuffle in administration | seven killed, 30 injured as boulder falls Siar Baba waterfall | Back Issues  
 
news details
'Conflict of interest' spoils SKIMS' faculty selection
7/12/2018 10:34:00 PM
Saahil Suhail
Early Times Report
Anantnag, July 12: : Apart from disputed eligibility of candidates and skewed marking pattern, the 'conflict of interest' has spoiled the faculty selection process at Sher-I-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences.
A crucial document, which Early Times has accessed, reveals the mystery behind the sudden ouster of Dr. M. S. Khuroo from the Governing Body and Apical Selection committee of this premier health institute.
Document detailing how the whole the selection process at SKIMS was manipulated and then sent to then Chairman Governing Body-Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti. But instead of ordering a probe or asking the committee to ensure transparency, the whistleblower was thrown out.
According to the document, SKIMS Apical Selection committee started holding interviews for the Direct Recruitment from July 2017 to December 2017. Interviews for 31 of the 40 specialties were completed and the selection list was finalized. Secretary Apical Selection Committee (then Director SKIMS, Prof. A. G. Ahanger) had kept few specialties for review by the members as there was inter-observer variation in scoring pattern in these specialties.
However, then in December 2017, SKIMS faced a major administrative problem as then Director SKIMS along with three senior faculty members were suspended/removed from their positions.
Prof. Omar Javed Shah took over as the next Director SKIMS according to government order and interview process restarted in late March/April 2018 for the left-over 9 specialties.
According to the document sent to then Chief Minister the interview process related to these left-over specialties under the new selection committee was uneven and fraught with many inconsistencies. There were several instances where the interview process was polluted by conflict of interests, which affected the fairness and transparency in the selections.
"Repeated attempts were made to bring some order to the system. The process was completed in late May 2018. On June 5, 2018, the minutes of APSC (Direct Recruitment) were circulated for signatures. On review, there were multiple aberrations/anomalies of diverse types in the minutes related to duplicate cumulative marks sheets in records, error in computing marks in to cumulative and master sheet, disputed eligibility of candidates, skewed marking pattern to candidates (either 10/10 or 0/10 saga).
In 2018, the impact of these errors to the fairness and transparency in the selection process was identified and necessary recommendations to correct such aberrations/errors were suggested. APSC took a decision to review the APSC minutes carefully and edit any aberrations/errors, typographic or otherwise. It was expected that the minutes of APSC (Direct Recruitment) will be edited considering the document submitted to the APSC and the edited list would be submitted for signatures by the members.
Insiders revealed that these aberrations had caused major disastrous effect on the selection process. A number of candidates were included in the recommended select list who were either non-eligible or did not figure in the selection list.
"A candidate was found in select list by scoring allotting 5 (instead of 0.5) out of 3 marks. This could be a case of "unintentional Cut and paste error" or "intentionally entered error to select wrong candidate," reads the documents.
Similarly, a non-eligible candidate was interviewed through some ingenious unscheduled interview months after the interview of the specialty was conducted; another non-eligible candidate was selected by an ingenious process. He figured in one of the 10 candidates in the specialty. This non-eligible candidate was given 10/10 score by the experts, while nine other candidates were failed in the interview. It is worth mentioning that some out of these 9 candidates had received high ranking by members, while the non-eligible candidate was given low score by members.
According to the documents, Chairman GB SKIMS (Chief Minister J&K state) was apprised of these aberrations and their impact to the transparencies of the results and a document was submitted to her office on June 5, 2018.
Surprisingly, on June 13 Dr. Khuroo was relieved of the responsibility of Vice-Chairman, APSC and member GB SKIMS.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU