x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Three men from Jammu and Kashmir detained in Chandigarh | IAF cautious and alert, says Air Chief BS Dhanoa amid Indo-Pak tensions | Normalcy returning in Jammu, students flock to schools in large numbers | Barricades removed in Srinagar’s commercial hub Lal Chowk | Jammu & Kashmir government's help saves Srinagar BPO from shutdown | Congress leader Ghulam Nabi Azad stopped at Jammu airport, being sent back to Delhi | Flood situation worsens in north India, most other states battle to stay afloat | Army man martyred, 4 injured in Pakistan firing along LoC in Poonch | Twitter Suspends 200 Pakistan Accounts After Anti-India Tweets on Kashmir | Jammu Police nabs rumour mongers from outskirts | Congress & Left Leaders are exposed after removal of Article 370, 35-A: BJP | AJKGRDS condemns demolishing of Guru Ravi Dass Mandir Tughlakabad | Youth Congress condemns detention of senior leaders | Srinagar's uptown markets stand with Modi's decision, resume business | After nukes, Rajnath talks about PoK | Suspense continues over future of JK administrative services, but officials hopeful | Last phase thrown open without inauguration for public convenience | Syed Geelani had internet, phone access during J&K lockdown, 2 BSNL officers suspended | With Kashmir under lockdown, ISPR running Geelani''s Twitter handle? | Munish reaches out to people at Shergarh | Will distribute my salary among needy' | Many schools open with thin attendance | No major law and order situation reported across valley, says J-K Director Information | J&K political parties under intelligence scanner | J&K cadre Ex IPS officer gets 15 years jail in 2009 Drug Case | DC reviews traffic management in Jammu city | Rehabilitation of shopkeepers: Div Com inspects newly constructed shops at Narwal | Anti-India violence not conducive to peace, PM Modi tells Donald Trump over phone call | SC Lawyer Seeks FIR Against Shehla Rashid For Accusing Army Of 'Ransacking Houses' in Kashmir | Northern Railway cancels/diverts trains due to operational reasons in several northern states | LS ex-MPs asked to vacate official bungalows within a week: Housing panel | Retirement age for all Central Forces personnel fixed at 60 years | Delhi High Court seeks response from Centre on Shah Faesal's detention at airport | Flights operations likely to be suspended for 2 weeks from Oct 1 | Former J-K DGP mocks Pak Army Chief | Schools reopen in Ramban; to reopen in Banihal tomorrow | News about seizure of weapons of J&K police SPOs is fake: Home Secy | In daring operation, IAF chopper successfully rescues 4 persons stuck in flooded Tawi river | Centre erred in abrogating Article 370 in J&K, must reverse decision: Ghulam Nabi Azad | Release of detained political activists begins in Kishtwar | Former IAS officer Shah Faesal moves court over detention at Delhi airport | West Pak refugees, Valmikis hopeful post Article 370 | Most educational institutions reopen in Jammu's border districts | NSA Ajit Doval briefs Amit Shah on J&K situation | Jammu-Srinagar National Highway reopened after three-hour-long blockade due to landslide | Holistic approach needed after revoking Article 370: Lt Gen Hooda | Several Gorkhas, Congress Sewa Dal members join BJP in Jammu | POJK DPs Front hails abrogation of Article 370 | Youth Congress condemns detention of senior leaders | JPU celebrates World Photographer Day | ROF urges Govt to resolve pending issues | Congress criticizes BJP for betraying people on statehood | BJP appeals masses not to pay heed to rumours | JTC, SKF demand permanent rehabilitation of KPs | Kailash Kund Yatra arrangements discussed | Back to village Program: 312 identified works started | J&K Bank lowers interest rate on loans by 0.10 pc | Maj Gen Sehrawat takes over as GoC of 71 Sub Area in Udhampur | DDC Poonch reviews working of offices, dev works | Miserbaly failure of prosecution leads to acquittal of charas smugglers | Govt appoints 12 ACFs, 3 Range Officers | Jammu traders demand extension of deadline for filing income tax, GST returns | Court reject bail in POCSO | News about seizure of weapons of J&K police SPOs is fake: Home Secy | Guv advisors review development, security in Doda, Kishtwar | Cong leader criticizes Government | Cross-LoC bus service from Poonch to Rawalakot suspended, 42 PoK residents stranded | Social Welfare Department organizes assessment camp under RVY | Anaemia Mukt Bharat: Workshop held | CBSM organizes composite Mushaira at Akhnoor | Canara Bank conducts bottom- up consultation process | Induction programme held at YCET | ESRM presents nukad "Zindgi Ka Sabak" | BLSKS presents Dogri musical play "Raja Mandlik" | Rich Harvest School organizes Investiture Ceremony | Jammu people participate in Anandutsav | SIPS wins 'Institution of the Year Award' | DPS Jammu excels in inter-school basketball tourney | SMVDU organizes workshop on classroom management | 2 J&K Bn NCC commences camp at Nagrota | NGO hails scraping of Article 370, 35-A | Pakistan threatens India with Atom Bomb | Whether abrogation of Article 370 and bifurcation of State of J&K is legitimate or not? | Bazigarh and Harijan Basti of Bagh-e-Bahu reel under acute shortage of civic amenities | Back Issues  
 
news details
Nehru did commit a mistake by declaring ceasefire in J&K
Defending the indefensible
7/20/2019 12:42:30 AM
Early Times Report
Jammu, July 19: Union Minister Amit Shah's June 28 statement in the Lok Sabha that Prime Minister JL Nehru's 1948 ceasefire helped Pakistan annex J&K's 1/3rd territories (now called PoJK and Gilgit-Baltistan) has not gone down well with the votaries of Nehruvian approach. They have advancing spurious arguments to defend the indefensible and are seeking to tell that the Indian Army was not in a position to get the aggression vacated.
Union Minister Amit Shah had claimed in the Lok Sabha while speaking on J&K that Nehru wrongly declared a ceasefire in 1948 and, as a result, one-third of the state was lost to India. The critics have been saying that "this is arguably corroborated by unverified reports that Gen Cariappa, who was the commander in charge of the fighting, disagreed with the ceasefire decision" and that "he felt India could regain all of Jammu and Kashmir if the Army was given three weeks more".
The critics of Shah have been advancing three arguments to defend the Nehru's uncalled ceasefire. In 1948, JL Nehru had three good reasons for ordering ceasefire. One is that "a decision to ceasefire is not determined by generals alone". The other argument is that "Nehru faced international pressure - specifically from the US - which a one-year-old country would have found hard to resist". And, their third argument is that the terrain and logistics were in Pakistan's favour. "Equally importantly, beyond the ceasefire line, the terrain and logistics were increasingly in Pakistan's favour whilst the forces our Army would have confronted would be the Pakistan army and not the Pathan Lashkars," the critics of Amit Shah and apologists of Nehru have been saying.
All the three arguments are as untenable as they are flawed. All the three arguments only suggested that India was not strong enough to defend its sovereignty; that the Indian Army was incapable of throwing the invaders out of J&K; that Pakistan was in a commanding position; and that India had not become a full-fledged state in the real sense of the term (even after Britain quit India) which could resist international pressure. No one could defend the indefensible. After all, the ceasefire gave J&K's 1/3rd territories to Pakistan on a platter and the territories Nehru allowed Pakistan to occupy were of strategic importance.
A peep into the history clearly suggests that Nehru ordered ceasefire to help his friend Sheikh Abdullah of Kashmir to become an undisputed Sultan of J&K. It is important to note that all the areas which have been under the illegal occupation of Pakistan since 1947-48 were part of Jammu and Ladakh and that not one person in those areas spoke Kashmiri. They were all ethnically, culturally, socially and linguistically different. Amit Shah only spoke the truth. It is a different matter that neither Vajpayee nor Narendra Modi during his first tenure took any step to integrate PoJK and Gilgit-Baltistan into India.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU